So What Is the Price of the Saint-Brieuc Manuscript? 850,000 Euros or 1.2 Million Euros

or the negotiating margin that a bookshop’s source code hands to its customers

Dear bibliophiles, good day.

By Olympe Marcelet, inspector of platforms, of emphatic keywords and of prices one would rather not display.

My colleague Raturon published yesterday the fine story of the Saint-Brieuc manuscript and its 3 successive prices. The first 2 appear in the sale record: estimated at €200 to €300, lot 77 was knocked down at €85,000, or €103,360 with the 21.6% buyer’s fees. He left me the 3rd, which can be found nowhere. Or almost…

The manuscript’s listing at the dealer’s is a model of its kind: complete, precise, learned, with the dating, the scriptorium, the collation, the pastedowns, 2 named and dated expert opinions, the provenance traced back. Where the price should appear, a single word: Inquire.

The custom is old and respectable. Beyond a certain amount, the price is not displayed, it is spoken. The buyer of a 9th-century codex is not a passing customer, and a dealer has the right to know whom he is talking to before talking money.

I have nothing to say against this convention, which still distinguishes an antiquarian bookshop from an ordinary sales site. After all, we are not on Catawiki or eBay…

It rests, however, on an assumption that is no longer true in a digital world: that the price is to be found only where the seller put it.

The pages of this site, like those of nearly all online trade, emit a series of tags invisible on screen… which for me are so many invitations to put on my spectacles.

They have telling names (the amount, the currency, the formatted label meant for social networks) and they exist to be read by machines: the preview that unfolds when a link is pasted into a messaging app, the comparison engines that harvest catalogues, the indexing robots. The shop generates them automatically from the “price” field of its own database. Hiding the display on screen does not empty that field; it remains readable at the tag level.

They can be read in 3 seconds, with no particular skill, by displaying the page’s source code. On the manuscript’s listing, as I write, they carry an amount: €850,000.

Another listing from the same shop confirms the mechanism: the autograph letter from Kafka to Robert Klopstock shows €45,000 on screen, and its tag carries the same amount, in the same field. In both cases the price is entered and transmitted. Only its display changes.

Now, as Alcide Raturon pointed out, an online publication by the Boston fair, whose 48th edition opens on 6 November, shows a different amount for this same manuscript: $1.4 million, or about €1.2 million.

2 figures in writing, then. One quietly announced to the public 2 months before the fair. The other entered in the listing, invisible on screen, readable by anyone who opens the source code. Some €350,000 separate them.

I have no idea what the lower figure represents, and I will refrain from deciding. A price asked earlier, which the update did not reach. A floor the dealer set for himself and entered in his system. The threshold below which he will not go. Each of these hypotheses is plausible, and I have no way of choosing between them.

The practical effect is the same in all 3 cases.

A collector who turns up at the stand in November, having spent 3 seconds in the source code, will not open the conversation at 1.4 million. He knows that a lower figure exists, written by the seller himself, and he knows by how much. The convention of price on request existed so that the dealer would choose the moment, the interlocutor and the amount he names. The technical layer of his own shop has transferred that advantage to whoever thinks of looking. And that potentially makes for a handsome saving.

I specify, to cut short any quibble, that none of this contravenes the customs of the trade. The customs code of the International League of Antiquarian Booksellers has an article on price clarity, but it concerns material offered in open shops and at fairs, not websites. Price on request online is beyond reproach. The consequence is this: at Boston, in November, this manuscript should carry a clearly indicated price. The figure will thus become public in 2 months, on a label, in front of everyone. The discretion at issue here will have lasted only as long as the online catalogue.

I have verified the mechanism on only 1 shop and 2 listings, one with the price displayed and the other without, and I have not inspected colleagues who follow the same custom. I would be surprised if Vienna were the only one concerned: this is the behavior of an online shop, not a Viennese invention, and those who recognize themselves will go and look at their own source code before smiling at this one.

Dear bibliophiles, dear booksellers, to your tags.

Editor’s note. Dealer’s listing: display “Inquire,” product tags carrying €850,000, last modification stated as 27 July 2026, 5 days after the second of the 2 expert opinions cited in the entry. Readings taken on 31 August 2026; the values may have changed since.

GUILDE · OM/BALISES

Document classified: restricted circulation.

La lettre du bibliophile

Si cette chronique vous a plu : recevez trois nouvelles par semaine — livres rares, reliures, enchères, et les Dossiers IGLI. 18 ans d'archives, quelques milliers de lecteurs.

Pas de pub, pas de revente de données. Désabonnement en un clic.

À lire ensuite

The main types of binding in old books

La hiérarchisation des exemplaires selon M. Christian Galantaris

Dear bibliophiles, good day.

By Barthélemy d’Arcole, Inspector of Bibliophilic Aesthetics and Modern Heresies to the Guild of Bibliopolices.

A book is also judged by its dress. The binding protects, but it also speaks: it tells the period, the taste, the care and sometimes the vanity of an owner. To learn to read it is to add a sense to reading, and an argument to any valuation.

The first distinction separates the paper-wrapped state (French broché: a simple paper cover, sewn, which is the original state of publication) from the bound book, covered in boards and a nobler material. Between the two, the half-binding, whose spine and corners are leather and whose sides are paper or cloth, is an elegant and widespread compromise. Note that for some modern books the original wrappers are more sought after than a later binding.

Then come the materials. Morocco, a close-grained goatskin, is the noblest and the most sought after; calf, supple and smooth, dominates the classical centuries; sheepskin, tanned sheep hide (French basane), more modest, dresses ordinary books, and one should not confuse it with chagrin, which is grained. Vellum and parchment, white and rigid, come from ancient times, while in the nineteenth century percaline and publisher’s cloth industrialise binding.

The decoration signs a period. The so-called “à la Du Seuil” binding, a double frame of gilt fillets enhanced with corner fleurons, is a seventeenth-century design, older in fact than the binder Augustin Du Seuil who gave it his name. The fanfare binding spreads the interlacing of the Renaissance; the dentelle (lace) binding, openwork borders typical of the eighteenth century; the mosaic binding inlays pieces of coloured leather; and the Jansenist binding, unlike all the others, gives up every decoration on the sides to put beauty in the material alone. The Romantic nineteenth century, for its part, multiplies tools and ornaments.

One must also know how to name what one is looking at: the boards, which are the two sides; the spine, with raised bands or flat; the headcaps, at the top and bottom of the spine; the corners; the edges, sometimes gilt or painted; and finally the endpapers, those inner leaves sometimes decorated with dominoté paper. To name is to be able to describe, and so to sell or buy knowingly. Some bindings also bear the signature of a great binder (Trautz, Lortic, Cuzin, Marius-Michel), a signature that adds value provided it is authentic, which is not always so; mistrust, here as elsewhere, is a form of respect.

To go further, see our pages on formats, first editions and bibliophily.

The dress does not make the book, but it always admits something about it. GUILDE · esthétiques — B. d’Arcole.

Document classified: restricted circulation.

Be the first to comment

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.